Friday, May 22nd, 2009
Mel Brooks’ First Film: The Critic (1963)
Before Spaceballs, before Blazing Saddles and even before the original (good) Producers, Mel Brooks made this funny short film called The Critic. It’s a satire of pretentious animated “art” shorts, with the voice of Brooks playing an old man poking at the movie as it goes on.
What I love is how hilariously unforgiving Brooks is of these types of films, suggesting the director could have done something useful with his life, like “make a shoe.” Even though the lead character is supposed to be considered rude for talking through the movie, the old man is ultimately pretty wise in his critiques. That provides a nice balance – like on South Park, when the writer’s “truth” is delivered in the closing monologue by a foul-mouthed child, here the pretentiousness is being called out by a cranky old man. An unreliable lead character can deliver the writer’s point in a funny, off-handed way.

Leave a Reply